A courtroom exchange involving Chief Justice of India Surya Kant took an unusual turn on Monday when a lawyer allegedly questioned the CJI's integrity and suitability for the office. The lawyer was subsequently escorted out of the courtroom, according to a report by LiveLaw, which cited advocates present during the proceedings.
The incident occurred at around 2 pm when the lawyer approached a bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana. He apologised for raising the issue outside the prescribed procedure and requested the judges to examine documents he had submitted to the Chief Justice's office on November 2.
He told the bench that he had not received a response to his representation and insisted that the matter required immediate attention. The case reportedly appeared to concern contempt proceedings against him.
According to LiveLaw, the Chief Justice asked the lawyer to wait, saying, "We will see, you just wait." The lawyer refused and allegedly made personal remarks about the CJI, telling him that he did not deserve to occupy the chair and lacked integrity.
The audio and video transmission of the proceedings was switched off following the exchange. Lawyers present in court said the individual was then escorted out. Some members of the legal fraternity reportedly urged the Chief Justice to take action over the incident.
Earlier courtroom confrontation involving CJI Surya Kant
Monday's episode is the second reported incident since July involving abusive or personal remarks directed at Chief Justice Surya Kant or other Supreme Court judges.
In July, advocate Prabal Pratap, who was arguing his own case, disrupted proceedings before a bench that did not include the CJI. He began by directing the judges to order the registration of an FIR against an Assistant Commissioner of Police in Lucknow.
When Justice KV Viswanathan questioned his language, asking whether he was issuing orders to the bench, Pratap reportedly went on to make abusive comments about Surya Kant, according to LiveLaw.
The bench chose not to initiate contempt proceedings at the time. It observed that Pratap appeared to be distressed and had medical conditions.
Lawyer had attempted to throw shoe at former CJI BR Gavai
Another incident took place in October 2025, when lawyer Rakesh Kishore allegedly tried to hurl a shoe at then Chief Justice of India BR Gavai during a court hearing.
Kishore was reportedly angered by remarks made by Gavai while the court was hearing a petition concerning the restoration of a damaged idol of Lord Vishnu at the Khajuraho temple complex in Madhya Pradesh.
Following the incident, Attorney General R Venkataramani granted consent for criminal contempt proceedings against the 71-year-old lawyer on October 16, 2025.