Breaking news:
PM Modi Inaugurates New Bengaluru Metro Stretch on Pink Line | Virender Sehwag's Son Aaryavir Named Player of the Tournament at U19 Asia Cup 2026 | Delhi Air Quality Remains 'Very Poor' at 352, Eight Monitoring Stations Record 'Severe' Levels
Logo

Law And Order Cannot Be Blanket Excuse To Stop Journalists From Reporting: Media Body Tells Supreme Court

The Network of Women in Media, India, has urged the Supreme Court to protect journalists, particularly women reporters, from police obstruction, detention, physical assault and sexual harassment while covering protests 

22-11-2026
image
   

The Network of Women in Media, India (NWMI), has challenged the Delhi Police's justification for restricting journalists during protests in the national capital, telling the Supreme Court that maintaining public order cannot come at the cost of press freedom.

In a rejoinder filed in response to the Delhi Police's affidavit, the media organisation argued that police action against reporters covering demonstrations in October had infringed their fundamental rights. The petition specifically highlighted allegations that journalists were forcibly removed, detained and assaulted, with women reporters also facing sexual harassment.

The protests in question took place following a call for action against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over alleged irregularities in the functioning of the Election Commission.

According to a report by news agency Press Trust of India (PTI), NWMI has sought judicial safeguards to ensure that journalists can perform their professional duties without arbitrary interference. Its plea covers protection against physical obstruction, forced removal from reporting locations, unlawful detention, assault and sexual harassment.

The organisation maintained that such incidents affect several constitutional protections, including personal liberty, bodily integrity, the right to pursue a profession and the freedom to collect and disseminate information.

To underline the importance of facilitating journalistic work, the petitioner pointed out that reporters regularly operate in highly volatile environments, including armed conflicts. It argued that the presence of potential risks should prompt authorities to ensure journalists' safety rather than prevent them from reporting.

The submission stated that protecting reporters while enabling their work should be the preferred response, even in situations involving significant security challenges.

NWMI REJECTS POLICE'S 'REEL-MAKER' ARGUMENT

The dispute follows an affidavit in which Delhi Police maintained that it respected press freedom while drawing a distinction between accredited or professional journalists and individuals making social media reels during the Jantar Mantar demonstrations.

NWMI rejected this distinction, arguing that describing certain individuals as 'reel-makers' appeared to be an attempt to justify the alleged detention and obstruction of journalists after the incidents had taken place.

The media body said the central question before the court was not whether police had the authority to maintain public order, but whether those powers could be exercised in a manner that interfered with legitimate journalistic activities.

It invoked Articles 14, 19(1)(a), 19(1)(d) and 21 of the Constitution, which protect equality before the law, freedom of speech and expression, freedom of movement and the right to life and personal liberty.

The petitioner also cited an October 11 direction of the Supreme Court concerning the protection of professional duties. The direction stated that lawyers, journalists and other professionals should not face obstruction or hindrance while carrying out their work.

NWMI argued that restrictions imposed in the name of public order must have a legal basis and cannot be used as a general justification for preventing media personnel from reporting.

WOMEN JOURNALISTS' SAFETY A KEY CONCERN

A significant part of the petition focuses on the alleged sexual harassment of women journalists during protest coverage.

NWMI submitted that harassment in the workplace or while performing professional assignments undermines women's dignity, physical security and ability to work without fear.

It further argued that such incidents have consequences beyond the individuals directly affected. When women reporters face unsafe conditions while covering public events, it can discourage their participation in journalism and create an environment where equal professional opportunities become difficult to exercise.

The organisation warned that this could have a wider chilling effect on press freedom by making journalistic work particularly unsafe for women.

Through its petition, NWMI has sought clear safeguards against arbitrary police action, including obstruction, forced removal, detention, assault and sexual harassment. It has urged the Supreme Court to ensure that journalists can gather and report information without their constitutional and professional rights being compromised.

Image

Lawyer Escorted Out of Supreme Court After Personal Remarks Against CJI Surya

A lawyer was removed from the Supreme Court courtroom on Monday after allegedly making personal and

Read More
Image

Plea in Supreme Court seeks deadline for safe drinking water, better sanitati

Citing a CAG report that found E. coli in drinking water at some stations, the petition seeks regula

Read More
Image

Big Victory for Tata Power as Bombay HC Quashes Tata Power Land Acquisition

The Bombay High Court has struck down Maharashtra's proposed acquisition of 84 hectares of Tata Powe

Read More